His site ranking cerainly speaks to his capabilities. I agree, a great SEO may be no where to be found in SEs. My company does SEO work for very large companies, usually as part of a larger design or usability project. Those clients don't look for vendors through search engines, so I don't waste my time and money competing for those listings. I'm sure many of "the best" don't either.
As for seo-guy, I have some sites that compete against some of his sites. I know the market. I know the profit margins and I know what it takes to get top ranking, and he does very well. Also, he does it without most of the rediculous spammy crap many of the other competitors use. Thus, my respect for his work.
|